«Ammonium» – the last dialogue in the Ancient traditon

Authors

  • Yana A. Dronova Belgorod National Research University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52575/2687-0967-2022-49-1-64-69

Keywords:

Early Byzantium, Gaza, Ammonius, Zacharias the Rhetorician, controversy, Christianity, Neoplatonism

Abstract

The article is devoted to the most important monument of Late Antique literature – the work of Zacharias (Scholastic) Rhetorician «Ammonius». This work is a polemical Christian work, composed in the classical ancient form of dialogue and is a large and serious work written against the neo-Platonists. On the part of the Gazan school, only three such polemical works were written: «Theophrastus» by Aeneas of Gazan, «Ammonius» by Zacharias (Scholasticus) the Rhetorician, and the fragment «refutation of Proclus» by the famous rhetorician of the Gazan school, Procopius. In Russian historiography, this work is poorly studied. In addition, these works are not published in Russian. In our work, we will focus only on the analysis of «Ammonium», and try to prove that this polemical work is the last dialogue in the ancient style. Zachariah's dialogue also demonstrates the Christian appropriation of Hellenic thought, typical of the Gaza school. Zachariah's philosophical dialogue is a work that should equally be seen as a product of the interaction of his ascetic and sophisti  surroundings.

Acknowledgements: The author expresses deep gratitude to the scientific supervisor, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor N.N. Bolgov.

Author Biography

Yana A. Dronova, Belgorod National Research University

Postgraduate Student, Department of World History, Belgorod National Research University, Belgorod, Russia

References

Rapava M. 1982. Traditions et innovations dans l’école néo-platonicienne d’Alexandrie: Ammonius Hermias et David l’Invincible. Bedi Kartlisa 40. P.: 216–227.

Aeneas of Gaza. 1962. Epistole. Ed. by L.M. Positano. Collana di studi greci 19. Napoli, Libreria scientifica editrice, 132.

Charrue J.M. 2010. De l’être et du monde: Ammonius, Plotin, Proclus, Paris, Klincksieck, 200.

Verrycken K. 2001. La métaphysique d’Ammonius chez Zacharie de Mytilène. Revue des sciences philosophiques et théologiques. Paris. № 85: 241–266.

Nissen Th. 1940. Eine christliche Polemik gegen Julians Rede auf den König Helios. Byzantinische Zeitschrift. Berlin. № 40: 15–22.

Dillon J., Russell D., Gertz S. 2014. Aeneas of Gaza. Theophrastus with Zacharias of Mytilene Ammonius. London, Bloomsbury, 180.

Sorabji R. 2003. Sordid deals and divine names in Ammonius’ Alexandria. Neoplatonism and Society. Cardiff, 245.

Gallicet E. 1978. Per una rilettura del Teofrasto di Enea di Gaza e dell’ Ammonio di Zacaria Scolastico (Parte II). Atti della Accademia delle Scienze di Torino. 112: 137–167.

Watts E. 2006. Creating the ascetic and sophistic melange: Zacharias Scholasticus and the intellectual influence of Aeneas of Gaza and John Rufus. Vol. 18, Number 1: Palestinian Christianity:

–164.

Colonna M.M. 1973. Zacaria Scolastico, Ammonia: Introduxione, testo critico, traduzione, commentario. Napoli, Ed., 222.

Blank D. 2012. Ammonius Hermeiou and his School in Lloyd Gerson. The Cambridge History of Philosophy in Late Antiquity. Cambridge, UP: 654–666.

Merlan P. 1968. Ammonius Hermiae, Zacharias Scholasticus and Boethius. Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies. Vol. 9: 193–203.

Obertello L. 2007. Proclus, Ammonius of Hermias and Zachariah Scholasticus: The Search after Eternity and the Meaning of Creation. Divine Creation in Ancient, Medieval and Early Modern Thought. Leiden, Brill: 173–189.

Klitenic W.S. 2013. Another Link in the Golden Chain: Aeneas of Gaza and Zacharias Scholasticus on Plotinus Enn. 4.3. Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies. 53: 146–155.

Champion M.W. 2006. Zacharias Scholasticus’ Ammonius. MA Thesis University of Melbourne: 298.

Tempelis E. 1998. The School of Ammonius, son of Hermias, on Knowledge of the Divine. Athens, Parnassos Literary Society, 184.

Watts E. 2005. Winning the Intracommunal Dialogues: Zacharias Scholasticus’ Life of Severus’. Journal of Early Christian Studies. 13: 437–464.

Gallicet E. 1978. La risurrezione dei morti in Enea di Gaza e in Zacaria Scolastico. Augustinianum. 18: 273–278.

Westerink L.G. 1962. The Alexandria School since Hermias. Anonymous Prolegomena to Platonic Philosophy. Introd., text, transl. by L.G. Westerink. Amsterdam: X–XIII.

Sorabji R. 2005. The Philosophy of the Commentators 200–600 AD. A Sourcebook. Vol. 1–3. L.; Ithaca (N. Y.), 456.


Abstract views: 108

Share

Published

2022-04-06

How to Cite

Dronova, Y. A. (2022). «Ammonium» – the last dialogue in the Ancient traditon. Via in Tempore. History and Political Science, 49(1), 64-69. https://doi.org/10.52575/2687-0967-2022-49-1-64-69

Issue

Section

Topical issues of world history